Welcome

About Us

Resources

2006 Index

Links

Contact Us

Home

Humor

'The Treasure Chest'


ELCA Home

 

People tell me that if others would tithe then they would as well, because then the system would work.  But if they give and others don't, then they feel they have wasted their money.


Weekly Reflection: Pastor Dana Reardon
May 24, 2004

Read
Archived
Columns


Do We Donate As 'Friend' or 'Foe'?

 

Sometimes I think that stewardship and giving within a congregation is a little like a game show.  Have you ever seen Friend or Foe on the game show network?

On Friend or Foe, teams of two compete for money by answering questions.  At the end, the two members of the winning team stand opposite each other and put their hands in the "Trust box" where they cast a vote.  If they both vote "Friend," they get to split the money they won and they both go home happy.  If one votes "Friend" and the other votes "Foe," then the one who voted "Foe" gets all the money and the "Friend" gets nothing.  If they both vote "Foe" they both go home with nothing. 

Neither of these last two scenarios is very satisfying.  If one votes "Foe" and gets all the money, he or she goes home rich but must feel pretty lousy.  And of course, the other one goes home not only poor but also probably feels like a sucker.  If they both say "Foe," then they get nothing and probably feel bad about themselves and one another.

I have been thinking that if all the people that attend churches regularly in Rhode Island (where I serve) tithed, we could more than end hunger in this state. We could do so much.  But what if I put in my 10 percent and you don't?  I feel like a sucker and you get to keep your money for yourself. 

Isn't that why many people don't give more?  They don't want to feel like a sucker when they are the ones contributing more than others?  People tell me that if others would tithe then they would as well, because then the system would work.  But if they give and others don't, then they feel they have wasted their money and they feel taken.

But what I give is between God and me on one level, and I need to give it whether you do or not.  When we put our hand into the trust box to decide our pledge for the year or thinking about what to put in the plate on Sunday we, are not only playing Friend or Foe with each other, we are also playing Friend or Foe with the one who created us and gave us everything.

God puts in a very large hand that holds all of us and votes, "Friend." And we know God is going to.  We are never going to feel like a sucker if we say "Friend" to God.  We know because that hand holds us up and picks us up when we sink like Peter in the Sea of Galilee.  We know because that hand laid upon us brings healing.  We know because Jesus opened that hand and said, this is my body.  We know because that hand has a nail hole in it.  We know because that hand says, "Peace be with you."  We know because that hand says, "Feed my sheep."

If we can sing "What a friend we have in Jesus," can we with the Spirit's help do less than say "Friend" and share what we have won or better yet been given with the mission He calls us to?

Lord, All that I have is thine alone, a trust O Lord from thee.  Amen

 

Copyright (c) 2004, The Rev. Dana Reardon. All rights reserved. Used by permission. Email her at mspastor@aol.com.
 

The Rev. Dana Reardon is pastor at St. Paul Evangelical Lutheran Church, Warwick, RI.  A lifelong Lutheran, she came to ordained ministry after 21 years in nursing, mostly in pediatric intensive care.  She graduated from Lutheran Theological Seminary at Philadelphia in 1998 and served 4 ½ years in Upstate New York before becoming a New Englander.  She is still trying to understand the accent.  While in the Upstate New York Synod she chaired the Stewardship Team.  That began her fascination with what makes stewards -- and more, what makes for generosity. She has three amazing daughters: Pastor Reardon says much of what she knows of life she learned from them.